Their Choice: A Collection of Dad’s Best Friend Stories

It’s three, 4th-of-July themed Dad’s Best Friend stories. It may be cooling down outside now, but these three stories are sure to heat you up. It’s all about alpha males who take what they want, surprise encounters, first times, and definitely unprotected.

Harper’s Choice

When Harper and her friends run into trouble at the town’s 4th of July Music Festival, she’s shocked to see her dad’s best friend Toby working as an EMT. She knew he retired from the Marine Corps last winter but hadn’t seen him for several years. She’s not surprised however to see that he’s hotter than ever and she still has a wild crush on him.

Toby isn’t surprised that alcohol, combined with an unusually hot summer day, has been keeping him busy at the 4th of July celebration. He is surprised though to find Harper, his best friend’s daughter, mixed up in all of it, and even more surprised to realize what an amazing young woman she has turned into. He knows she’s off limits but when he unexpectedly discovers her in his shower, passionately shouting his name, he can no longer keep his hands to himself.

After a passion-filled holiday weekend someone with power threatens to out their relationship and they’re faced with a life changing decision.

Emma’s Choice

Emma fled the Buffington dynasty to get away from her overly controlling father to find work in a small mountain diner, where she can be anonymous and enjoy the life she wants. But when her dad’s best friend Carter shows up to bring her home, he jeopardizes her happiness.

While she’s had a mad crush on the retired Army Ranger her entire life, not even he can persuade her to go back and live under her father’s thumb.

When Carter sees Emma, and realizes what a beautiful woman she’s become, he knows he’s in trouble. But he knows she’s strictly off limits. Her dad hired him to bring her back, and that’s all he will do.

But when she frustrates him to the breaking point, and he decides to discipline her, they both realize there’s no going back.

Lily’s Choice

When Lily’s dorm building burns down she has to scramble for new housing before school starts in the fall. Thankfully, her dad’s best friend Steele, has an apartment over his garage that she can rent.

And even though she has always thought Steele is the sexiest man she’s ever laid eyes on, as a man who’s twice her age, and her dad’s best friend, he’s off limits.

Or he’s supposed to be, anyway.

When Steele’s ex-girlfriend shows up at his 4th of July BBQ party uninvited, and he sees Lily flirting with her college friends, tempers flare, passion ignites and the forbidden becomes the inevitable.

Excerpt:

When Lily’s dad Mike called from Florida asking if I knew of a place for her to stay her last year of college, I happily offered my place. I hadn’t seen her in several years and was surprised to discover how grown up she is.
As in long legs, perky tits, full pink lips grown up which instantly gave me a hard on. What kind of jerk gets hard around his best friend’s daughter? Even if she is old enough to drink?

And now she’s in my pool messing around with two college aged guys, who are clearly in good shape, and even more clearly into her and I feel a rage building inside of me. For some reason she’s in her clothes and her tank top clings to her tits while her hard nipples show through and I want to yank those two clowns out of the pool by the scruffs and send them on their way. I wonder if she’s sleeping with one of them. Or both.

Do they put her on her back, spread her thighs and revel in her sweet pussy? The thought of either one of them penetrating her tight hole while she screams in delight makes me want to punch something.

After she dropped by the other day to pick up a key to the apartment, I can’t stop thinking about her. She was wearing a filmy sundress that I wanted to lift up so I could stare at her perfect ass while I paddled it red. And now all I want to do is peel off her wet clothes, bend her over one of the lawn chairs, and drive my wickedly hard shaft up her pussy.

But I can’t because she’s my best friend’s daughter, she’s half my age, and she’s way out of bounds for me so I put on the best smile I can manage and say, “Hey guys, having fun?” through clenched teeth.

“Hello sir!” one of them greets me. While I’m used to strangers addressing me that way now, especially when I’m in uniform, coming from the young man who’s standing next to my soaking wet and incredibly sexy tenant this time it makes me cringe.

Makes me sound old. Which I am, compared to these three. “I hope it’s okay, that we’re in your pool, we just thought we’d take a break from moving Lily,” he explains.

I must look like such a jerk standing here glaring at them. Of course I don’t mind if they use my pool. I just want them to enjoy it with someone other than Lily.

“Sure it’s okay, I’m glad you’re enjoying it. It’s a nice day and someone should be using it. I just came home to get some lunch.” I give them a wave as I head into the house to eat. And hopefully give myself some relief my throbbing hard cock is begging for.

It’s like I’m a horny college student all over again desperate to put my cock in the nearest pretty girl’s pussy. I may regret letting Lily stay here after all if I can’t keep my libido in check.